An accused has had his appeal against his surrender dismissed by the Supreme Court. The appellant has been accused of crimes of indecent assault, and one offence of gross indecency, from over forty years ago, which he allegedly committed against his two sisters. He is appealing his surrender which is sought under the Trade and Cooperation Agreement between the European Union and the European Atomic Energy Community, and the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland (“TCA”). The TCA is the post-Brexit treaty, signed between the UK and the EU, the Treaty also provides the system under which this appellant may be surrendered for conviction and sentencing.
In part, the appellant argued that if convicted, he would face a heavier sentence, than he would have, if he had been convicted closer to the time of the alleged offences. Building on this, it would violate his Article 7 rights under the European Convention on Human Rights ("The Convention") and Article 49 of the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union ("The Charter"), both of which prohibit retrospective criminalisation and the imposition of a heavier penalty than was applicable when the offence was committed.
The appellant's case relies on the evidence, which was provided to him by a Junior Counsel in the UK, who practices in several areas including criminal law. This counsel is of the "firm opinion" that the appellant would face a heavier sentence if convicted. This opinion was the basis of the appellant's appeal.
Mr Justice Hunt of the High Court considered the commonality of the systems in both Ireland and England and Wales, finding that it is likely that a higher sentence would be imposed but that this alone was not a violation of rights under the Convention or the Charter.
The Chief Justice, Mr Justice O'Donnell considered and outlined relevant law. Section 37 of the European Arrest Warrant 2003 sets out several considerations which apply in cases where it is alleged that fundamental rights have been breached, including if the surrender would be incompatible with the state's obligations under the Convention or its Protocols or a contravention of the Constitution, among other things.
O'Donnell CJ applied legal tests and concluded that rejecting surrender or extradition based on the Constitution could occur if the possible treatment of the person who is to be surrendered would be in direct contravention of Constitutional values. Second, the Court considered when the Convention would prevent a surrender or extradition, in cases where the surrender would breach the person's rights under the ECHR, or where the State itself has already breached their obligations under the Convention.
Lastly, if the Charter precludes the surrender or extradition, the Court distinguishes between EU member states and non-member states, stating that where the rights in the Convention and the Charter correspond, then the ECtHR should apply.
Ultimately, the appeal was dismissed, the Court stating that "the objection does not come close to satisfying the legal test for a refusal to surrender".