European Court of Justice has answered questions posed by the High Court in relation to Slots at Dublin Airport

The European Court of Justice has answered questions posed by the High Court regarding the interpretation of legislation on the allocation of slots at coordinated airports. Since 2007, Dublin Airport has been considered a 'Coordinated airport', defined in Council Regulation (EEC) No. 95/93 on common rules for the allocation of slots at Community airports, a coordinated airport is one which needs the assistance of a coordinator to schedule or allocate a slot for take-off or landing (with the exceptions of State Flights, emergency landings or humanitarian flights). The Irish Aviation Authority (IAA) determines the parameters for the slot allocation and oversees Ireland's responsibilities under various regulations and directives. 

In 2007, after an environmental assessment had been carried out, An Bord Pleanála provided permission for the development of Terminal 2. The consent to the building of Terminal 2 at Dublin Airport included a condition that the combined total number of passengers shall not exceed 32 million per annum (32mmpa). The further expansion of Terminal 1, Dublin Airport, in 2008 was also subject to the passenger cap.  

In 2024, for the first time since 2007, it was forecast by the Dublin Airport Authority (DAA), that the number of passengers could exceed the cap. The IAA's interim decision was to set seasonal caps to spread the cap evenly across the year. However, the DAA, alongside several other aircraft carriers, brought an action to the High Court, as they felt adversely affected by the imposition of the cap. 

The High Court referred three questions to the Court of Justice. Firstly, can the 32mmpa be considered a relevant capacity limit when deciding how many flight slots Dublin Airport can allocate? Secondly, if yes to the first question, and the passenger cap can be taken into account, can the state reduce the number of flight slots that are allocated for a particular season, even if that means some airlines do not receive slots, they would normally be entitled to under the EU slot rules? Thirdly, can the managing company temporarily close the airport to limit the number of passengers to the cap and not exceed the annual limit? 

In respect of the first, the Court found that the passenger cap cannot be ignored and that it is an element of the real capacity of the airport and must be considered. The Court considered the wording of Article 6 of the Regulations and determined that the rules require slot allocation to reflect the real airport capacity, be it legal or physical in nature. The passenger cap is a legal constraint therefore, it must be considered when setting the airport's coordination parameters. 

Secondly, the Court determined that because of the cap, the airport can reduce the number of slots available for a season, thus limiting the number of slots allocated per airline. As such, at the end of each scheduling period, slots must be returned to the pool of slots to be re-allocated, while an airline has priority over the slots it is not entitled to the slots. Ultimately, the Court did not answer the third question, as the passenger cap is a relevant capacity constraint, and the cap will be enforced by way of the slots being allocated. 

Click here to read the judgment.  

Share

Resources

Sustaining Partners