The Court of Appeal of England and Wales has upheld admissions criteria used by a Church of England school, finding that although the arrangements placed non-white applicants and those of non-English ethnic origin at a disadvantage, they were a proportionate means of preserving the school's religious character.
In R (CKT) v Twyford CofE Academies Trust & Ors [2026] EWCA Civ 1364, the Court considered whether faith-based admissions criteria amounted to unlawful indirect racial discrimination under section 19 of the Equality Act 2010.
The proceedings were brought by a mother and son originally from Eritrea who attended an Eritrean Orthodox church. The son had unsuccessfully applied for admission to Twyford Academy, a designated Church of England school operated by the defendant Trust.
Of the school's 190 places, 150 were reserved for Christian applicants and allocated using a points-based system where applications were oversubscribed. Applicants could receive up to 20 points for regular church attendance, with an additional point awarded to those attending a Church of England church or another church in communion with it.
Although the applicant received 20 points for regular attendance, he was denied the additional point because the Eritrean Orthodox Church was not in communion with the Church of England. Admissions statistics indicated that virtually all successful applicants for the reserved places had received the maximum 21 points.
The claimants challenged the arrangements, alleging indirect racial discrimination and a failure to comply with the public sector equality duty under section 149 of the 2010 Act.
The High Court dismissed the claim, accepting that the criteria disadvantaged certain racial and ethnic groups but finding that they were justified as a proportionate means of maintaining the school's Anglican ethos.
Delivering the Court of Appeal's judgment, Lord Justice Lewis confirmed that the statutory exemption permitting faith schools to discriminate on grounds of religion or belief did not extend automatically to discrimination involving other protected characteristics, including race. Such claims therefore remained subject to the proportionality assessment required by section 19.
The Court nevertheless upheld the High Court's assessment, finding that the judge had correctly applied the four-stage proportionality test established in Bank Mellat v HM Treasury (No 2) [2013] UKSC 39.
The Court considered that Parliament's express recognition of faith schools and religious admissions criteria supported the legitimacy of preserving a school's religious ethos. It also acknowledged that those responsible for religious schools were generally better placed to assess the measures necessary to maintain their particular character, although such decisions remained subject to judicial scrutiny.
The availability of places at other schools operated by the Trust, which did not apply religious admissions criteria, was also relevant to assessing whether less restrictive alternatives existed.
The Court further rejected the claim that the Trust had breached its public sector equality duty, finding that it had considered the potential racial impacts of its admissions arrangements and measures to mitigate them.
Accordingly, the Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal, confirming that faith-based admissions criteria may be lawful despite creating racial disadvantage where they pursue a legitimate aim and satisfy the requirements of proportionality.